Answer key: The Codebreaker’s Notebook

For teachers: key, plaintext and teaching tips for every stage, and a checker for proof codes.

Check a proof code

Enter the name as the student typed it. Upper and lower case don’t matter.

1 Page 1: The rule Caesar

Key
+19
Ciphertext
TZHHW VHWXU KXTDX KYBKL MEHHD LYHKI TMMXK GL
Plaintext
A GOOD CODEBREAKER FIRST LOOKS FOR PATTERNS
In class
Caesar with shift 19. Without spaces, students have to read across the groups.

2 Page 2: A story from Baghdad Caesar

Key
+12
Ciphertext
YADQF TMZMF TAGEM ZPKQM DEMSA MEOTA XMDUZ NMSTP MPZMY QPMXW UZPUI DAFQM NAAWM NAGFE QODQF IDUFU ZSUZU FTQPQ EODUN QPMOX QHQDF DUOWU ZQHQD KXMZS GMSQE AYQXQ FFQDE MDQGE QPYGO TYADQ ARFQZ FTMZA FTQDE UZQZS XUETF TQYAE FOAYY AZXQF FQDUE QRAXX AIQPN KFMZP MURMY QEEMS QUEID UFFQZ IUFTM EUYBX QEGNE FUFGF UAZQH QDKQN QOAYQ EFTQE MYQEQ ODQFX QFFQD EAFTQ XQFFQ DFTMF MBBQM DEYAE FARFQ ZUZFT QEQOD QFFQJ FBDAN MNXKE FMZPE RADQI UFTFT UEUPQ MMXWU ZPUOA GXPDQ MPYQE EMSQE FTMFZ ANAPK IMEEG BBAEQ PFADQ MPFAP MKIQO MXXTU EFDUO WRDQC GQZOK MZMXK EUE
Plaintext
MORE THAN A THOUSAND YEARS AGO A SCHOLAR IN BAGHDAD NAMED AL-KINDI WROTE A BOOK ABOUT SECRET WRITING. IN IT HE DESCRIBED A CLEVER TRICK. IN EVERY LANGUAGE SOME LETTERS ARE USED MUCH MORE OFTEN THAN OTHERS. IN ENGLISH THE MOST COMMON LETTER IS E, FOLLOWED BY T AND A. IF A MESSAGE IS WRITTEN WITH A SIMPLE SUBSTITUTION, EVERY E BECOMES THE SAME SECRET LETTER. SO THE LETTER THAT APPEARS MOST OFTEN IN THE SECRET TEXT PROBABLY STANDS FOR E. WITH THIS IDEA AL-KINDI COULD READ MESSAGES THAT NOBODY WAS SUPPOSED TO READ. TODAY WE CALL HIS TRICK FREQUENCY ANALYSIS.
Question
What was the name of the scholar? → Al-Kindi (also: Kindi, Al Kindi)
In class
Caesar with shift 12. The most common cipher letter is Q (= E). Ask: why does counting work here but not on page 1?

3 Page 3: The unbreakable cipher Vigenère

Key
BAGHDAD
Ciphertext
WIMLQEUF WGZ FAOMEJ AKE XOBXLDKDCLK JLPKFR LVU TKSEK OXNGSEJ FHAUT
Plaintext
VIGENERE WAS CALLED THE UNBREAKABLE CIPHER FOR THREE HUNDRED YEARS
In class
Keyword BAGHDAD from page 2. The same plain letter turns into different cipher letters, so counting no longer helps directly.

4 Page 4: The queen’s letters Substitution

Key
CQKHFSXIBMJPDRLEZWYVTUANOG
Ciphertext
BR VIF OFCW 1586 DCWO, ZTFFR LS YKLVY, ACY C EWBYLRFW BR FRXPCRH. YIF AWLVF YFKWFV PFVVFWY VL SWBFRHY AIL EPCRRFH VL YFV IFW SWFF. VIF PFVVFWY AFWF IBHHFR BR VIF QFFW QCWWFPY VICV AFWF HFPBUFWFH VL IFW ILTYF. QTV VIF DFYYFRXFW ACY ALWJBRX SLW VIF LVIFW YBHF. FUFWO PFVVFW ACY KLEBFH CRH XBUFR VL VILDCY EIFPBEEFY, VIF QFYV KLHFQWFCJFW LS VIF FRXPBYI ZTFFR. DCWO TYFH C KBEIFW VICV WFEPCKFH PFVVFWY ABVI YODQLPY. EIFPBEEFY KLTRVFH VIF YODQLPY, KLDECWFH VIFD ABVI VIF PFVVFWY LS VIF PCRXTCXF CRH QWLJF VIF KLHF. VIF PFVVFWY AFWF TYFH CY FUBHFRKF CXCBRYV IFW, CRH IFW EPCR SCBPFH.
Plaintext
IN THE YEAR 1586 MARY, QUEEN OF SCOTS, WAS A PRISONER IN ENGLAND. SHE WROTE SECRET LETTERS TO FRIENDS WHO PLANNED TO SET HER FREE. THE LETTERS WERE HIDDEN IN THE BEER BARRELS THAT WERE DELIVERED TO HER HOUSE. BUT THE MESSENGER WAS WORKING FOR THE OTHER SIDE. EVERY LETTER WAS COPIED AND GIVEN TO THOMAS PHELIPPES, THE BEST CODEBREAKER OF THE ENGLISH QUEEN. MARY USED A CIPHER THAT REPLACED LETTERS WITH SYMBOLS. PHELIPPES COUNTED THE SYMBOLS, COMPARED THEM WITH THE LETTERS OF THE LANGUAGE AND BROKE THE CODE. THE LETTERS WERE USED AS EVIDENCE AGAINST HER, AND HER PLAN FAILED.
Question
Where were the secret letters hidden? → beer barrels (also: barrels, in beer barrels, in barrels, beer barrel, barrel, the beer barrels)
Hint
Short words help: a one-letter word is A or I, and THE is the most common three-letter word.
In class
Monoalphabetic substitution with the word spaces kept. Work as a class in the projector mode (“Solve together”): fill in the frequent letters first, then guess words.

5 Page 5: The last page Vigenère

Key
PHELIPPES
Ciphertext
NVY SIKT VWPK XSM LWSDT USEMQDSC. LLPNWBT XG IOI NWSTFJTHOPZH
Plaintext
YOU HAVE READ THE WHOLE NOTEBOOK. WELCOME TO THE CODEBREAKERS
In class
Keyword PHELIPPES from page 4. A long keyword, but once known, decryption is routine.

Searches the list of pages on this site. What you type stays in your browser.